In Ontario, the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) empowers workers to refuse unsafe work without fear of reprisal. This critical protection ensures employees can prioritize their safety when faced with dangerous conditions. Below, we break down the legal framework, process, and limitations of refusing unsafe work in Ontario, along with practical steps to protect your rights.

‍

The Legal Right to Refuse Unsafe Work

Under Section 43(3) of the OHSA, workers may refuse work if they have “reason to believe” that:

1. Equipment or machinery they are to use is likely to endanger themselves or others.
2. The physical condition of the workplace (e.g., structural hazards, poor ventilation) poses a danger.
3. Workplace violence is likely to occur, such as threats from a client or colleague.
4. The employer is contravening OHSA regulations, creating a risk of harm.

‍

Key Legal Test:

• The worker’s belief must be both subjective (genuine) and objectively reasonable based on the circumstances.
• The danger need not be immediate but must pose a “real or significant possibility” of harm.

‍

Who Can Refuse Work?

Most Ontario workers are covered, but exemptions apply to:

• Healthcare workers (e.g., hospitals, nursing homes) if refusing would endanger a patient’s life.
• Police, firefighters, and correctional staff during emergencies.
• Workers in industries where danger is a “normal condition of employment” (e.g., firefighters entering burning buildings).

‍

The Work Refusal Process: Step-by-Step

‍

1. First Stage: Immediate Reporting

• Notify your supervisor of the refusal and your safety concerns.
• The employer must investigate immediately in the presence of:
  
  • The refusing worker.
  • A worker safety representative (e.g., union rep, joint health and safety committee member).
• The worker must remain in a safe place near their workstation during the investigation.

‍

2. Second Stage: Escalation to the Ministry of Labour

• If unresolved, the worker, employer, or union contacts a Ministry of Labour (MLITSD) inspector.
• The inspector investigates and issues a written decision. If hazards exist, the employer must remedy them.
• During the investigation:
  
  • The employer may assign alternative work to the refusing worker.
  • Another worker can perform the refused task only if informed of the refusal and reasons in the presence of a safety representative.

‍

Protection Against Reprisals

Employers cannot discipline, demote, or terminate workers for lawful refusals. Penalties for reprisals include fines up to 25,000 for individuals and 25,000 for individuals and 500,000 for corporations, plus reinstatement and compensation for lost wages.

‍

Special Considerations

‍

Group Refusals

• Multiple workers can refuse simultaneously if exposed to the same hazard, but each must individually articulate their concerns to avoid the refusal being labeled a strike.
• Collective action risks disciplinary action if motivations are deemed non-safety-related.

‍

Workplace Violence

• The law has clarified that workers need only show a “significant possibility” of harm, not certainty.
• Employers must conduct annual workplace violence risk assessments and update safety protocols.

‍

Employer Obligations

1. Investigate promptly and document findings.
2. Train workers and supervisors on refusal procedures and hazard reporting.
3. Maintain records for at least 3 years.
4. Foster a safety culture by addressing hazards proactively.

‍

Practical Steps for Workers

1. Document hazards: Take photos, save emails, and note unsafe conditions.
2. Follow the OHSA process: Never walk off the job without notifying your supervisor.
3. Contact your union or a lawyer if facing retaliation or unresolved issues.

‍

Key Takeaways

• The OHSA grants a broad right to refuse unsafe work, but exemptions exist for critical sectors.
• Employers must investigate and resolve refusals promptly or face penalties.
• Workers must act in good faith and follow procedural steps to retain legal protections.

‍

Free Consultation with London Employment Lawyers

‍

Ontario’s laws provide critical protections for employees during mass layoffs, ensuring they receive fair notice, severance pay, and support. If you’re affected by a group termination, understanding your rights and seeking professional advice can help you navigate this challenging time and secure the compensation you deserve. Please do not hesitate to contact our experienced Ottawa employment lawyers for a free legal consultation. Randy Ai Law Office can be contacted at (548) 489-2006 or fill out the contact form.

‍